Investing · Americans in France · 5 min read · Updated
Assurance vie for Americans in France: what the IRS sees
For an American living in France, an assurance vie keeps its French tax advantages but gets none of them from the IRS. The U.S. sees a foreign account that goes on the FBAR and Form 8938, funds inside it that are PFICs in Xpat's reading, and a contract whose own U.S. classification is disputed. What it holds decides how hard the U.S. return gets.
Does the IRS recognize an assurance vie?
No. The French advantages of an assurance vie, lower tax on withdrawals after a minimum holding period and favorable treatment on death, are written in French law, and the U.S. taxes its citizens and green-card holders on their worldwide income as if the contract were any other foreign investment. The treaty does not change that.
So the question for the U.S. return is not "is this an assurance vie" but "what is this contract, and what is inside it". There are three layers: the funds in the contract, the contract itself, and the account it counts as for reporting.
Are the funds inside an assurance vie PFICs?
In Xpat's reading, yes for the unit-linked part. Units of account (unités de compte) are shares of non-U.S. funds, and a non-U.S. fund is a PFIC when at least 75% of its income is passive or 50% of its assets produce passive income, which describes almost every fund. Each one then generally needs a Form 8621 and is taxed harshly on gains.
The insurer's euro fund (fonds en euros) is different: you hold a claim on the insurer, not fund units, so in Xpat's reading it raises no PFIC problem, though the contract still has to be reported. Customers have told Xpat that they found out only after years of saving that the assurance vie their bank had opened for them was full of PFICs.
PFICs: why French funds, PEA and assurance vie cause trouble explains the PFIC tax and the two elections that soften it.
Is an assurance vie life insurance for U.S. tax?
Not necessarily, and preparers disagree. U.S. law treats a contract as life insurance only if it is life insurance under local law and also passes one of two actuarial tests in section 7702 of the Internal Revenue Code. Many French contracts are savings products with little insurance in them, and whether a given contract passes is decided contract by contract.
If a contract fails, section 7702 taxes the policyholder each year on the growth of its surrender value, as ordinary income, even with no withdrawal. Some preparers instead treat the whole contract as a single PFIC, and a few as a foreign trust, which would add Form 3520. None of these readings is settled, which is why the classification is worth fixing with a professional before the first U.S. return that includes the contract.
| How a preparer may treat the contract | What it means on the U.S. return |
|---|---|
| Look through to the funds inside (Xpat's reading) | Form 8621 for each fund in the unit-linked part; the euro fund is reported but not a PFIC |
| Life insurance that fails section 7702 | Yearly growth of the surrender value taxed as ordinary income |
| The whole contract as one PFIC | One Form 8621 for the contract; PFIC tax on withdrawals and surrender |
| A foreign trust | Form 3520 and related filings; rare and disputed |
Does an assurance vie go on the FBAR and Form 8938?
Yes, in every reading. The contract has a surrender value held by a French insurer, so it counts toward the FBAR when all your non-U.S. accounts together pass $10,000 at any time in the year, and toward Form 8938 when your foreign assets pass $200,000 at year-end or $300,000 at any time (single, living abroad), or $400,000 and $600,000 on a joint return.
How are withdrawals taxed in France and in the U.S.?
France taxes only the gains in a withdrawal, with an allowance and a lower rate once the contract has been held long enough, plus social charges (service-public.gouv.fr: how assurance vie income is taxed). The U.S. taxes the same gain under whichever classification applies: as a PFIC distribution, as ordinary income already counted under section 7702, or under the default rules. The French tax is then credited on the U.S. return.
Two gaps remain. The French tax on an assurance vie is often lower than the PFIC tax, so U.S. tax is left to pay; and the U.S. may tax growth years before France does, so the credit and the tax do not fall in the same year. The 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax cannot be reduced with French tax at all.
The U.S. also has an excise tax on premiums paid to a foreign insurer, reported on Form 720 by the person who pays the premium (IRS Instructions for Form 720). Whether it applies to a given French contract depends on the insurer's position under the treaty, so ask the insurer before paying new premiums.
What can Americans in France do with an assurance vie?
There is no single answer, because it depends on what the contract holds, how long it has been open, and how your preparer classifies it. The usual options are these, each to check with a professional first.
- Keep it and report it: list the contract on the FBAR and Form 8938, and file Form 8621 for the funds inside, or whatever your preparer's classification requires.
- Move the unit-linked part to the euro fund: in Xpat's reading this stops new PFIC exposure, though in the same reading switching out of a fund is itself a PFIC disposal, taxed as one.
- Stop adding money and invest new savings outside the contract, in holdings the U.S. treats simply.
- Close it: weigh the French cost of an early surrender against the U.S. cost of keeping it.
Xpat's investment planner shows PFIC-screened alternatives, such as individual company shares, with the tax on dividends where you live. It is an illustration, not advice: PFIC status is tested each year, and a screen is not a guarantee.
I never reported my assurance vie. What now?
If the contract, its funds or the FBARs were left off past returns and the failure was not deliberate, the streamlined procedure lets you catch up by filing the last 3 returns and 6 FBARs without the offshore penalty.
Find a professional who handles PFICs and foreign insurance on Get help, and read how to file U.S. taxes from France and the U.S.–France tax treaty explained for the rest of the return.
Questions people also ask
Is an assurance vie tax-free for Americans in France?
No. Its tax advantages are French. The U.S. taxes an American in France on the contract's income and gains under its own rules, and the funds inside are PFICs in Xpat's reading.
Do Americans in France report an assurance vie on the FBAR?
Yes. Its surrender value counts toward the FBAR when your non-U.S. accounts pass $10,000 in total, and toward Form 8938 above its thresholds.
Can an American in France open an assurance vie?
Whether to accept a U.S. person is the insurer's decision. Before opening one, check with a preparer how the contract will be treated on the U.S. return, since the funds inside are PFICs in Xpat's reading.
Sources
Every figure on this page comes from Xpat's law data, which names its sources and when they were checked. This guide is general information, not tax advice.