Taxes · Americans in France · 5 min read · Updated
FEIE or foreign tax credit: which suits Americans in France?
Americans in France remove U.S. tax on French wages in one of two ways: the foreign earned income exclusion (Form 2555), which takes up to $132,900 of foreign earned income off the U.S. return for 2026, or the foreign tax credit (Form 1116), which subtracts French tax from the U.S. tax on the same income. French income tax is shared out by household, so for families it can fall below the U.S. tax on the same wages, and the better choice depends on who is in the household.
How does the foreign earned income exclusion work in France?
The exclusion removes French wages and self-employment income from U.S. tax, up to $132,900 for 2026. It needs a tax home in France and one of two tests: a full tax year as a bona fide resident abroad, or a minimum number of full days outside the U.S. in a 12-month period (IRS: foreign earned income exclusion). The same IRS page describes a separate housing exclusion on top of it.
It covers earned income only. French pensions, interest, dividends, PEA gains and rent stay on the U.S. return either way, and are handled with the credit.
How does the foreign tax credit work with French tax?
The credit subtracts the French income tax paid on French income from the U.S. tax on that same income. Under the treaty, France taxes French wages first and the U.S. gives the credit. Credits you cannot use this year carry forward, which helps in a later year when France taxes you more than the U.S. does.
What counts as French tax matters. Income tax counts. In Xpat's reading, most other employee contributions are social security, which the totalization agreement deals with instead, while the CSG and CRDS on wages are creditable, which adds to the French tax available to offset U.S. tax.
Why is French income tax sometimes lower than U.S. tax?
France taxes the household, not the person. Wages are reduced by a standard 10% allowance, then the income is divided into tax shares: 1 for a single person, 2 for a couple, plus 0.5 for each of the first two children and 1 from the third. The scale below then applies to each share.
| Income per tax share | French marginal rate |
|---|---|
| Up to €11,600 | 0% |
| €11,600 to €29,579 | 11% |
| €29,579 to €84,577 | 30% |
| €84,577 to €181,917 | 41% |
| Above €181,917 | 45% |
The U.S. taxes the same income at 10% to 37% after a standard deduction of $16,100 for a single filer, $32,200 for a married couple filing jointly, with no division by household size. In Xpat's reading, for a single person on a middle or high salary, French income tax plus CSG and CRDS usually covers the U.S. tax on the wages. For a couple with children, the tax shares can bring French income tax well below the U.S. tax on the same wages, and the credit alone may leave some U.S. tax to pay.
What does each choice cost?
| Exclusion (Form 2555) | Credit (Form 1116) | |
|---|---|---|
| Income it covers | French earned income, up to $132,900 in 2026 | Any French-taxed income, by category |
| When French tax is low (large household) | Removes U.S. tax on wages up to the limit | U.S. tax can remain |
| Child tax credit | Refundable part lost | Up to $1,700 per child stays refundable |
| Unused French tax | Cannot be credited on excluded wages | Carried to later years |
| Changing your mind | Revoking blocks it for 5 tax years without IRS approval | Chosen each year |
| Net Investment Income Tax | Excluded wages count back in the threshold | French tax cannot reduce it |
The child credit cuts both ways for families. The exclusion can remove U.S. tax on French wages where the credit would not, but anyone who files Form 2555 gives up the refundable part of the child tax credit. With the credit, a family whose U.S. tax on wages is already covered can receive up to $1,700 per child from the IRS.
Which one do Americans in France usually choose?
For a single salaried employee, or a couple without children, the credit usually fits: French income tax with CSG and CRDS usually covers the U.S. tax, unused credits carry forward, and nothing locks in. For families, Xpat's reading is that the answer is closer: the exclusion may remove more U.S. tax, while the credit keeps the refundable child credit. Running the return both ways is the only way to know.
Some people combine them: they exclude wages and use the credit for French tax on other income, such as interest or rent. French tax on the wages that were excluded cannot also be credited.
Above $132,900 of wages, the exclusion stops and the stacking rule taxes the rest at the higher U.S. rates; the credit then has to cover that part anyway.
Xpat's simulator shows the marginal rates on each kind of income in France and the U.S.; a preparer who knows both systems can compute both returns (how to find one). The same choice for the UK is explained in FEIE or foreign tax credit in the UK.
Where can U.S. tax remain whichever you choose?
The 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax applies to investment income above $200,000 (single) or $250,000 (joint) of modified income, and French tax cannot reduce it. Wages excluded with Form 2555 are added back when testing that threshold.
French investment income is taxed at the flat tax of 31.4% and the U.S. credits it, but income France barely taxes, such as gains inside a PEA, leaves little to credit. French funds are PFICs on the U.S. return whichever way you treat your wages (why). And neither the exclusion nor the credit removes U.S. self-employment tax: for the self-employed, the totalization agreement decides which country's social security applies.
Questions people also ask
Is the foreign tax credit or the exclusion better for Americans in France?
For a single person or a couple without children, the credit usually removes U.S. tax on French wages and keeps future options open. For families, French tax shares lower French income tax, so the exclusion can remove more U.S. tax, at the cost of the refundable child credit. Compute both.
Can I credit French CSG and CRDS against U.S. tax?
In Xpat's reading, yes: the CSG and CRDS on French wages are treated as creditable income taxes, unlike most other French social contributions. Ask a preparer to confirm how they treat them on your return.
Does the exclusion cover my French pension?
No. Pensions are not earned income. French social security pensions are taxable only in France under the treaty, and other French income is handled with the foreign tax credit.
Sources
Every figure on this page comes from Xpat's law data, which names its sources and when they were checked. This guide is general information, not tax advice.